- buy from $9.99
Tomatometer®reviews counted: 0see all City Island reviews
Exactly the kind of family dramedy I was looking for since quite a while, but wasn't able to find one. Liked how the plot is set & executed without coming across as a drag: It's about how almost every main character has their own set of secrets & how they try their best to keep it, but it all finally comes out for good. The only, yet the biggest, drawback of this movie was Emily Mortimer's unnatural performance. Her overacting (and it's not like she was meant to act that way) really got on my nerves (otherwise, my rating would have been greater than 7/10). It's one of the worst performances by any actress I've seen in quite a while. Andy Garcia, as usual, is excellent. The rest of the cast is good enough. If you're looking for a good time-pass flick, go for it.
- imrealgod, Tuesday, September 21, 2010
Cast: Andy Garcia, Julianna Margulies, Emily Mortimer, Dominik Garcia-Lorido, Alan Arkin, Steven Strait, Ezra Miller, Carrie Baker Reynolds, Hope Glendon-Ross, Curtiss Cook Director: Raymond De Felitta Summary: When he recognizes his son, Tony (Steven Strait), whom he hasn't seen in more than 20 years, among a crop of new inmates in the jail where he works, Vince Rizzo (Andy Garcia) decides to bring the troubled young man home with him, much to the surprise of his wife and kids. My Thoughts: "This film has all the dysfunctional family quirks that make a great Indie comedy. The script is fresh and very funny. This is a family built on secrets with hilarious sarcasm. The family is believable. I know families like this, I happen to be a part of one. Very loud and sarcastic. But also full of love. It was a great surprise. Didn't know much about the film before seeing it and I ended up loving it. Probably one of my favorite Andy Garcia films. Julianna Margulies was great at the sexually frustrated wife. But the one who stood out more for me in this film was Ezra Miller. Just a very funny kid. His one-liners where really funny. He was a natural. But the one who I don't think anyone will mind looking at in this film was Steven Strait playing Tony Nardella. Damn.. That's all I'm going to say on that.. lol.. To get back to the film, it was great and I recommend everyone rent this one. It won't disappoint."
- LWOODS04, Saturday, September 11, 2010
The Rizzo household is full of secrets. Vince (Andy Garcia) is out "playing poker", but he's actually too embarrassed to admit that he's taking an acting class. His wife Joyce (Julianna Margulies)thinks he's having an affair and lets it drive her crazy. Vince's daughter Vivian (Dominik Garcia-Lorido) is home from school on break, not alerting her parents that she had been suspended and was saving up for her tuition by stripping. Their son Vince, Jr. (Ezra Miller) is into looking at chicks on the internet. Sounds normal? Well, he likes looking at overweight girls being fed. Add on top of all this the con Tony (Steven Strait) that Vince brings home on an early release that he feels is his duty due to something way back in his past. You know that this many secrets are going to unravel at some point. The other star in the film is City Island itself, a small fishing village that sits between Manhattan and the Bronx.It's like Martha's Vineyard between these two great seas of humanity. You get a closed in feeling as the characters keep running into each other, almost spilling the secretes each one bears. The cast is particularly good with Andy Garcia deliver one of his best performances in years (yes, better than Pink Panther 2) playing the prison guard/struggling actor. City Island is another one of those ensemble comedies that hinges on its cast. The cast in one of these films can either make or break it and City Island scores because of its cast and a nice little story that isn't preachy, isn't too ridiculous, and can be moving at times without being a total sap fest. It's one of those little films out there that outshines the schlock Hollywood is deliver in brown paper bags every Friday.
- sononothing, Tuesday, August 31, 2010